Start Investing

The Most Expensive Football Cards of All Time

Photo by Nick Carnera

The Most Expensive Football Cards of All Time
Cameron Joshua


American football is hands-down the most watched sport in America, and for good measure, the NFL is the highest valued professional sports league in the US. The Dallas Cowboys, valued at $6.5 billion, is the most profitable franchise, with the average NFL team assessed at $3.48 billion.


 

In light of all this, perhaps it comes as no surprise that interest in the NFL trading card market has remained strong. From the earliest days of the American Professional Football Association to the modern era, here are the most expensive football cards, which embrace the entire history of the NFL.


 

1. 2017 National Treasures NFL Shield Patrick Mahomes Autographed Rookie Card #161

 Sold in July 2021 for $4,300,000 by PWCC Marketplace


Source: PWCC

 

On March 21, 2017, Panini released 2017 National Treasures as a premium football card product, highlighting Patrick Mahomes' NFL Shield Rookie Patch Autograph card as the most valuable football card in the hobby. 


The illustrious serial numbered 1/1 card acquired a BGS 8.5 for its condition and a BGS 10 for Mahomes' signature. After signing the richest contract in NFL history for ten years, $450 million, expectations are high for Mahomes, the Chiefs, and collectors who latch onto his coveted football cards.

 

2. 2000 Playoff Contenders Tom Brady Championship Ticket Autograph Rookie Card #144

Sold in June 2021 for $3,107,372.40 by Lelands Auctions 


Source: Lelands Auctions


While currently sitting as the 2nd most expensive football card, when Tom Brady's 2000 Playoff Contenders Rookie Autograph card sold in June 2021, it set the record for the most valuable football card at the time. 


Brady's ground-breaking rookie card obtained a BGS 9 for condition and a BGS 10 for his autograph, along with a limited serial number of /100. Tom Brady is arguably the greatest player in NFL history behind seven Super Bowl rings and five Super Bowl MVPs, ensuring continued interest in his football cards.

 

3. 1958 Topps Jim Brown Rookie Card #62

Sold in November 2016 for $358,500 by Heritage Auctions

 

Source: Heritage Auctions


After nine unparalleled NFL seasons, Jim Brown, recognized as one of the greatest running backs in NFL history, was inducted in 1971 to the Pro Football Hall of Fame in Canton, Ohio. There are 3,619 Jim Brown 1958 Topps rookie cards in PSA's population report, though only five cards, around .001%, merited a PSA 9, the card's highest grade. 


While fans can only wonder about the potential statistics Jim Brown could have accumulated after abruptly ending his NFL career, the intrinsic value of his rookie card is unmatched by rookie cards of any non-quarterbacks.

 

4. 2000 SP Authentic Tom Brady Rookie Card #118

 Sold in April 2021 for $312,000 by Goldin Auctions

 

Source: Goldin Auctions


Upper Deck issued the second most valuable Tom Brady rookie card within 2000 SP Authentic. The highly coveted rookie card starring Tom Brady received a BGS 10 and is limited to /1250. As one of the most accomplished players in the game's history, collectors can expect Tom Brady's rookie card to consistently rank at the top of any football card list.

 

5. 2017 Panini Flawless Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card #4

Sold in March 2021 for $312,000 by Goldin Auctions

Source: Goldin Auctions

 

Issued by Panini, the highlight of 2017 Flawless is without a doubt Patrick Mahomes' NFL Shield. Like 2017 National Treasures, Mahomes' rookie patch autograph card from Panini Flawless is limited to 1/1. The condition of the card achieved a BGS 7.5, with the autograph drawing a BGS 10. While Mahomes continues his prowess as an NFL superstar, the price tag of his rookie cards continues to soar.

 

6. 1957 Topps Bart Starr Rookie Card #119

 Sold in February 2017 for $288,000 by Heritage Auctions


Source: Heritage Auctions

 

Bryan Bartlett Starr led the Green Bay Packers to victories in Super Bowl I and II, becoming one of the most celebrated Packers, and cementing himself in the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 1977. 


Bart Starr's most treasured rookie card emerged from 1957 Topps, warranting a PSA 9. According to PSA's population report, Bart Starr's 1957 Topps rookie card is highly condition sensitive, as only three of 1,710 cards, roughly 0.001%, warranted a PSA 9, with no card graded higher.

 

7. 1965 Topps Joe Namath Rookie Card #122

Sold in February 2018 for $264,000 by Heritage Auctions

 

Source: Heritage Auctions


After leading the New York Jets to their only Super Bowl victory in franchise history in Super Bowl III, "Broadway" Joe Namath is one of the most recognizable NFL players. Namath's rookie card from 1965 Topps is by far the most coveted card of the set. With a PSA population of 1,402, only five cards, approximately 0.003%, have earned a PSA 9.

 

8. 2000 Bowman Chrome Tom Brady Rookie Card #236

Sold in March 2021 for $233,700 by Goldin Auctions

 

Source: Goldin Auctions


Securing his 3rd appearance in the top 10 most valuable football cards, Tom Brady's 2000 Bowman Chrome refractor rookie card is a true gem. Beckett graded Brady's monumental rookie card a BGS 9.5, one of only 31 other cards to receive the BGS 9.5 grade. 


According to the BGS population report, only one 2000 Bowman Chrome Tom Brady rookie card received a BGS 10. As Brady's 2000 Bowman Chrome rookie card already holds significant value, if the BGS 10 were to surface, one could potentially see the card surge up this list.

 

9. 1976 Topps Walter Payton Rookie Card #148

 Sold in February 2021 for $228,000 by Heritage Auctions

 

Source: Heritage Auctions


The only card on the list not graded by PSA or BGS, the late Walter Payton's 1976 Topps rookie card is a true masterpiece. Payton's iconic rookie card obtained a Sportscard Guaranty Corporation (SGC) Gold Label 10. Second to only Emmitt Smith in career rushing yards, Walter Payton, was the pioneer of the stiff arm and was also arguably the greatest running back in NFL history.

 

10.  1935 National Chicle Bronko Nagurski Rookie Card #34

Sold in August 2019 for $174,000 by Heritage Auctions


Source: Heritage Auctions

 

The 10th most valuable football card is also one of the earliest football cards in history. Bronko Nagurski's historic football card from 1935 National Chicle received a PSA 8.5, with only one card receiving a higher grade. Nagurski, one of the most intimidating players in NFL history, played both fullback and linebacker for the Chicago Bears in the 1930s. Inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 1963, Nagurski's rookie card is a true grail of the hobby.

 


***


The Otis platform has several football cards available for investment, including: the Patrick Mahomes Rookie Card RPA (2017 National Treasures Holo Silver #161 /25 BGS 9.5) and the Tom Brady Rookie Card (2000 SP Authentic #118 /1250 PSA 10). 

OTIS WEALTH, INC. (“OTIS”) OPERATES THE WITHOTIS.COM WEBSITE (THE “SITE”) AND A MOBILE APP-BASED PLATFORM (THE “APP”), AND IS NOT A BROKER-DEALER OR INVESTMENT ADVISER. ALL SECURITIES-RELATED ACTIVITY IS CONDUCTED BY DALMORE GROUP, LLC (“DALMORE”), A REGISTERED BROKER-DEALER AND MEMBER OF FINRA (WWW.FINRA.ORG) AND SIPC (WWW.SIPC.ORG), LOCATED AT 525 GREEN PLACE, WOODMERE, NY 11598. YOU CAN REVIEW THE BROKERCHECK FOR DALMORE HERE. AN UP-TO-DATE DALMORE FORM CRS IS AVAILABLE HERE.

YOU SHOULD SPEAK WITH YOUR FINANCIAL ADVISOR, ACCOUNTANT AND/OR ATTORNEY WHEN EVALUATING ANY OFFERING. NEITHER OTIS, ITS AFFILIATED ISSUERS NOR DALMORE MAKES ANY RECOMMENDATIONS OR PROVIDES ADVICE ABOUT INVESTMENTS. THE SITE AND THE APP MAY MAKE FORWARD-LOOKING STATEMENTS. YOU SHOULD NOT RELY ON THESE STATEMENTS BUT SHOULD CAREFULLY EVALUATE THE OFFERING MATERIALS IN ASSESSING ANY INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY, INCLUDING THE COMPLETE SET OF RISK FACTORS THAT ARE PROVIDED FOR YOUR CONSIDERATION.

OTIS GALLERY LLC (“GALLERY”) AND OTIS COLLECTION LLC (“COLLECTION”) ARE CONDUCTING PUBLIC OFFERINGS PURSUANT TO REGULATION A AND PRIVATE OFFERINGS PURSUANT TO REGULATION D UNDER THE SECURITIES ACT OF 1933, AS AMENDED, THROUGH THE APP. THE OFFERING CIRCULAR FOR GALLERY CAN BE FOUND HERE, AND THE OFFERING CIRCULAR FOR COLLECTION CAN BE FOUND HERE. THE PRIVATE PLACEMENT MEMORANDUM FOR ANY OFFERING CONDUCTED PURSUANT TO REGULATION D HAS BEEN OR WILL BE, AS APPLICABLE, DISTRIBUTED DIRECTLY TO INVESTORS. PAST PERFORMANCE IS NO GUARANTEE OF FUTURE RESULTS. INVESTMENTS SUCH AS THOSE ON THE OTIS PLATFORM ARE SPECULATIVE AND INVOLVE SUBSTANTIAL RISKS TO CONSIDER BEFORE INVESTING, OUTLINED IN THE RESPECTIVE OFFERING MATERIALS AND INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, ILLIQUIDITY, LACK OF DIVERSIFICATION AND COMPLETE LOSS OF CAPITAL. KEY RISKS INCLUDE, BUT ARE NOT LIMITED TO, LIMITED OPERATING HISTORY, LIMITED DIVERSIFICATION, RISK OF ASSET DAMAGE OR THEFT AND LACK OF VOTING RIGHTS. ALSO, THE ADVERSE ECONOMIC EFFECTS OF THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC ARE UNKNOWN AND COULD MATERIALLY IMPACT THIS INVESTMENT. AN INVESTMENT IN AN OFFERING CONSTITUTES ONLY AN INVESTMENT IN A PARTICULAR SERIES AND NOT IN OTIS, GALLERY, COLLECTION OR THE UNDERLYING ASSET(S). INVESTORS SHOULD CAREFULLY REVIEW THE RISKS LOCATED IN THE RESPECTIVE OFFERING MATERIALS FOR A MORE COMPREHENSIVE DISCUSSION OF RISK.

INVESTMENT OVERVIEWS CONTAINED HEREIN CONTAIN SUMMARIES OF THE PURPOSE AND THE PRINCIPAL BUSINESS TERMS OF THE INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITIES. SUCH SUMMARIES ARE INTENDED FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY AND DO NOT PURPORT TO BE COMPLETE, AND EACH IS QUALIFIED IN ITS ENTIRETY BY REFERENCE TO THE MORE-DETAILED DISCUSSIONS CONTAINED IN THE RESPECTIVE OFFERING CIRCULAR FILED WITH THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION (“SEC”) OR OTHER OFFERING MATERIALS RELATING TO SUCH INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY.

FROM TIME TO TIME, AFFILIATES OF OTIS WILL SEEK TO QUALIFY ADDITIONAL SECURITIES UNDER REGULATION A. FOR OFFERINGS THAT HAVE NOT YET BEEN QUALIFIED, NO MONEY OR OTHER CONSIDERATION IS BEING SOLICITED AND, IF SENT IN RESPONSE, WILL NOT BE ACCEPTED. NO OFFER TO BUY SECURITIES CAN BE ACCEPTED, AND NO PART OF THE PURCHASE PRICE CAN BE RECEIVED, UNTIL AN OFFERING STATEMENT FILED WITH THE SEC HAS BEEN QUALIFIED BY THE SEC OR UNLESS AS STATED IN THE OFFERING MATERIALS RELATING TO AN INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY, AS APPLICABLE. ANY SUCH OFFER MAY BE WITHDRAWN OR REVOKED, WITHOUT OBLIGATION OR COMMITMENT OF ANY KIND, AT ANY TIME BEFORE NOTICE OF ACCEPTANCE GIVEN AFTER THE DATE OF QUALIFICATION BY THE SEC OR AS STATED IN THE OFFERING MATERIALS RELATING TO AN INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY, AS APPLICABLE. AN INDICATION OF INTEREST INVOLVES NO OBLIGATION OR COMMITMENT OF ANY KIND.

OTIS DOES NOT OFFER REFUNDS AFTER AN INVESTMENT HAS BEEN MADE. PLEASE REVIEW THE RELEVANT OFFERING MATERIALS AND SUBSCRIPTION DOCUMENTATION FOR MORE INFORMATION.

AN ACTIVE TRADING MARKET FOR ANY SERIES OF GALLERY OR COLLECTION INTERESTS MAY NOT DEVELOP OR BE SUSTAINED. IF AN ACTIVE PUBLIC TRADING MARKET FOR GALLERY OR COLLECTION INTERESTS DOES NOT DEVELOP OR IS NOT SUSTAINED, IT MAY BE DIFFICULT OR IMPOSSIBLE FOR YOU TO RESELL YOUR INTERESTS AT ANY PRICE. EVEN IF AN ACTIVE MARKET DOES DEVELOP, THE MARKET PRICE COULD DECLINE BELOW THE AMOUNT YOU PAID FOR YOUR INTERESTS. THERE IS NO ASSURANCE THAT THE OTIS PLATFORM WILL PROVIDE AN ACTIVE MARKET FOR RESALES OF GALLERY OR COLLECTION INTERESTS. FURTHER, WITHOUT THE OTIS PLATFORM, IT MAY BE DIFFICULT OR IMPOSSIBLE FOR YOU TO DISPOSE OF YOUR INTERESTS. IF THE MARKET DEVELOPS FOR ANY SERIES OF GALLERY AND/OR OTIS COLLECTION INTERESTS, THE MARKET PRICE OF SUCH INTERESTS COULD FLUCTUATE SIGNIFICANTLY FOR MANY REASONS, INCLUDING REASONS UNRELATED TO PERFORMANCE, THE UNDERLYING ASSETS OR ANY SERIES, SUCH AS REPORTS BY INDUSTRY ANALYSTS, INVESTOR PERCEPTIONS OR ANNOUNCEMENTS BY COMPETITORS REGARDING THEIR OWN PERFORMANCE, AS WELL AS GENERAL ECONOMIC AND INDUSTRY CONDITIONS.